People across america are donning Face Masks For COVID-19 in an attempt to curb transmission of the coronavirus. But there isn’t enough data to know for sure whether such cloth masks may prevent an infected person from spreading the virus to someone else, experts say.
Within the face of evidence that the coronavirus may spread by talking and breathing, on top of coughing or sneezing, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommended April 3 that individuals cover their faces with cloth or fabric when going outside in public areas.
Cloth may cut down on some large respiratory droplets coming from a cough or sneeze, but it’s unclear whether it will likewise catch smaller droplets called aerosols which are released by just breathing or talking.
Cloth masks, as well as surgical masks, are made to protect others from virus spread through the mask wearer, not the other way around. Those infected with the virus that causes COVID-19 can transmit it to others before they start showing symptoms (SN: 3/13/20). When the masks are worn as a general habit, they make an effort to prevent people who are unaware they are sick from unwittingly transmitting the virus to others. Wearing a mask is not really meant to be a replacement for social distancing, handwashing and other efforts.
Scientists and journalists share a core belief in questioning, observing and verifying to achieve the reality. Science News reports on crucial research and discovery across science disciplines. We must have your financial support to make it work – every contribution is important.
But there are few studies evaluating the effectiveness of Face Masks For Coronavirus at preventing respiratory diseases from spreading, researchers from your U.S. National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine wrote inside an April 8 letter towards the White House Office of Technology and science Policy.
People who do exist advise that fabric masks may capture large respiratory droplets, like those from the cough or even a sneeze. Those made from different types of cloth have a wide-ranging capacity to filter virus-sized particles, having a trade-off between filtration and capability to breathe.
In one study, a mask that used 16 layers of handkerchief fabric managed to filter out 63 percent of 300-nanometer-sized particles. (The coronavirus is between 50 to 200 nanometers in diameter.) But that mask was harder to breathe with compared with thick, tight-fitting N95 respirators, often used in hospitals, that can block minuscule particles. Wearing a cloth mask with that many layers could be uncomfortable and may “cause some to pass out,” the researchers wrote in the letter.
See all of our coverage of the 2019 novel coronavirus outbreak
Surgical masks are somewhat less mysterious. Those Face Masks For COVID-19 may reduce transmission of influenza and seasonal coronaviruses that can cause common colds from individuals with symptoms, researchers report April 3 in general Medicine. Researchers quantified the volume of virus exhaled by participants both with and without having a surgical mask over 30 minutes.
Those masks significantly reduced the volume of detectable influenza virus in respiratory droplet particles, as well as the quantity of seasonal coronaviruses in aerosols.
Irrespective of how well they work, the prosperity of cloth or surgical masks at protecting others is dependent upon whether people wear the gear properly – including keeping it in place – and making sure it doesn’t get too wet. Moisture, such pqcish from breathing, can trap virus in a mask and make it a strong source of contamination if the wearer takes them back.
Even though the evidence for fabric masks is sparse, health officials should still encourage people to use face masks, other researchers write in an April 9 analysis within the BMJ. Limited protection could still save lives. “As with parachutes for jumping out of aeroplanes, it really is time to act” without waiting around for evidence, the authors say.